BambooHR Recruiting Module Review: Great HRIS, Mediocre ATS
BambooHR Recruiting Module Review: Great HRIS, Mediocre ATS
Let's be clear from the start: BambooHR is an excellent HRIS platform. It handles employee data, time off, performance reviews, and onboarding beautifully. But when it comes to recruiting? It's... fine. Not great, not terrible, just fine.
User reviews on G2 give BambooHR's recruiting features 4.3 out of 5 stars, but when you read the actual reviews, there's a pattern: people love the HRIS, tolerate the recruiting module.
What BambooHR Recruiting Actually Offers
BambooHR's recruiting module (technically called "Applicant Tracking System" but it's really just a bolt-on to their HRIS) provides basic applicant tracking functionality.
According to BambooHR's product page, you get:
- Job posting and distribution to major job boards
- Candidate pipeline management with basic kanban view
- Interview scheduling (manual coordination, not automated)
- Offer letter generation that syncs with HRIS for onboarding
- Basic hiring analytics showing time-to-fill and source effectiveness
The killer feature? Seamless transition from candidate to employee. When you hire someone in BambooHR, their candidate profile automatically becomes their employee profile. No data re-entry, no duplicate records, no integration headaches.
"That's why we use it," admits a recruiting leader in a Capterra review. "Not because the recruiting features are amazing, but because the handoff to HRIS is frictionless."
What Works Well
User reviews on TrustRadius and G2 highlight several strengths:
Simplicity: BambooHR recruiting isn't trying to be enterprise-grade. It's straightforward, clean, and easy to use.
"I set it up in an afternoon without any training," reports one HR generalist on Software Advice. "For small companies that don't have dedicated recruiting teams, that simplicity is valuable."
Job Board Integration: BambooHR posts to Indeed, ZipRecruiter, LinkedIn, Glassdoor, and other major boards with one click. Not revolutionary, but it works.
Candidate Communication: Email templates, automated responses, and status updates are solid. According to user reviews on Capterra, the email system is "better than most ATS platforms, actually."
Mobile App: BambooHR's mobile app lets hiring managers review candidates, leave feedback, and advance candidates from their phone. Reviews on the App Store give it 4.7 stars for usability.
Reporting: While not as deep as dedicated ATS platforms, BambooHR provides useful reports on:
- Source effectiveness (which job boards produce hires)
- Time-to-fill by role and department
- Pipeline conversion rates
- EEO/diversity tracking
What Doesn't Work Well
Here's where BambooHR recruiting falls short compared to dedicated ATS platforms:
Limited Sourcing Capabilities: BambooHR has no built-in sourcing tools. You can't search LinkedIn, build talent pools, or do anything beyond managing applicants who apply to your jobs.
"It's applicant tracking, not talent acquisition," explains a recruiting manager in a G2 review. "If you're actively sourcing passive candidates, you need another tool."
Basic Interview Management: Interview scheduling is manual. There's no automated scheduling, no calendar optimization, no panel coordination. You're back to email ping-pong to find time slots.
Multiple reviews on TrustRadius mention this as the biggest pain point: "Why do I have a recruiting system that can't schedule interviews automatically? It's 2025."
No Advanced Analytics: Compared to platforms like Ashby or Greenhouse, BambooHR's recruiting analytics are basic. You get high-level funnel metrics, but nothing about interviewer performance, candidate quality scores, or pipeline velocity.
Limited Customization: The candidate pipeline stages are fixed. You can rename them, but you can't add complex workflows, conditional logic, or automated actions based on candidate status.
A recruiting operations specialist on Capterra notes: "BambooHR recruiting works great if your process is simple and linear. If you have complex approval chains or unique workflows, you'll fight the system constantly."
Chrome Extension Limitations: BambooHR has a Chrome extension for adding candidates from LinkedIn, but user reviews on G2 say it's "clunky" and "crashes frequently." Compared to tools like SeekOut or LinkedIn Recruiter, it's a significant downgrade.
Integration Ecosystem
Here's an interesting dynamic: BambooHR integrates well with other tools, which some teams use to compensate for its recruiting limitations.
According to BambooHR's integration marketplace:
- Assessment tools: Criteria Corp, Wonderlic, HackerRank
- Background checks: Checkr, Sterling, GoodHire
- Video interviewing: Spark Hire, myInterview
- Skills testing: TestGorilla, Codility
"We use BambooHR for the core ATS and integrate with better tools for everything else," explains a talent acquisition director on Reddit. "It's more work to manage multiple platforms, but we get best-in-class functionality where it matters."
Pricing: The Hidden Gotcha
BambooHR doesn't publish pricing publicly, but user discussions on Quora and PeerSpot reveal some patterns:
HRIS pricing:
- Typically $6-$8 per employee per month for core HRIS features
- Minimum commitments around $3,000-$5,000 annually for small companies
Recruiting add-on:
- Usually $3-$5 per employee per month additional
- May be included free for companies over 75 employees
For a 50-person company: $5,400-$7,800 annually for HRIS + recruiting.
That's competitive with other HRIS platforms, but 2-3x more expensive than standalone ATS options like Greenhouse or Lever for recruiting-only functionality.
The Real Question: Buy or Build?
The decision isn't really "Should we use BambooHR recruiting?"
The real question is: "If we already use BambooHR HRIS, should we add the recruiting module or buy a separate ATS?"
User sentiment on G2 suggests:
Stick with BambooHR recruiting if:
- You're a small company (under 100 employees) with simple hiring needs
- You hire fewer than 50 people per year
- You don't have dedicated recruiting staff
- HR generalists handle recruiting along with other responsibilities
- You value simplicity and unified data over advanced features
Get a separate ATS if:
- You're hiring 100+ people per year
- You have dedicated recruiters who need advanced tools
- You do active sourcing of passive candidates
- You run complex interview processes with panels and multiple rounds
- You care about deep recruiting analytics and optimization
The Verdict
I'm giving BambooHR recruiting 3.8 out of 5 stars.
It's a convenient, simple recruiting module that works well for small companies that already use BambooHR HRIS and don't have complex hiring needs. The seamless candidate-to-employee transition is genuinely valuable.
But if you're a serious recruiting organization doing high-volume hiring, you'll quickly outgrow it and need a dedicated ATS. Don't let the HRIS integration convenience trap you in a recruiting tool that limits your effectiveness.
The bottom line: BambooHR recruiting is great for companies where HR does recruiting as a side job. It's not built for companies where recruiting is the job.
Choose accordingly.
Sources:
Reach 1000s of Recruiting Professionals
Advertise your recruiting tools, services, or job opportunities with The Daily Hire
AI-Generated Content
This article was generated using AI and should be considered entertainment and educational content only. While we strive for accuracy, always verify important information with official sources. Don't take it too seriously—we're here for the vibes and the laughs.